I was WRONG
I take it all back…
Festivals and Animals
In the summer of 2003 I was asked by someone at the v2003 music festival the inevitable question of:
“So who is your favourite band?”
I answered, quite unreservedly “Athlete“.
It was, for me, a very confusing answer. You see, my musical line has for many years began and ended with Ben Folds Five, yet, sadly, they had split and although Ben Folds still carries the torch he is no longer part of a musical group.
I pondered on the answer to the question all of the festival weekend and thankfully my answer was backed up when the band performed a flawless set in the summer sunshine.
For a long while after this I lauded the band as an musical gem. Selling them to all of my friends and anyone else who would listen.
Their first album “Vehicles and Animals” was a triumph. I loved every song and played it half to death. Its the perfect feel-good exciting album, with more to boot. Intelligent, well crafted and excellently produced.
Never Meet your Heroes (or Athletes)
Sadly, cracks appeared in my Athlete love affair a couple of years later when 2 things happened:
1, they released a new critically acclaimed, but somewhat watered down and IMO bellow par 2nd album (Tourist).
2, I met and interviewed the band before a gig in Sheffield.
The first issue is clear. I did not and still do not like the ‘Tourist’ album. I have particular distaste for ‘Wires’ the bands first real big hit single. Its boring, bland and for me sells a false representation of the band. Instead of the vibrant, exciting Athlete I had fallen for ‘Wires’ shows them off as a bland sub-par-indie-rock mess.
Meeting the band should have been a truly wonderful experience for me, but I couldn’t suck up the fact that they had given me a DOA 2nd album.
Killer Question
Among the many questions (most of which were designed to cut through the clear tension the band gave off) I asked something along the lines of:
Your first album is a triumph. Excellent from start to end! For ME its the perfect album. So, why does the new album feel so drab and uninspiring?
The band were stunned to silence. The manager, who had sat in on the interview appeared open mouthed as he sat behind his laptop. (Keep reading)